8.4 a year ago · Redfin's active listings ÷ homes sold a month
—
Buyers and sellers
Redfin publishes this for 50 large metros, not this one
−1,931
Net moves in
Jul '24 to Jul '25 · people, from elsewhere in the US · −1,434 the year before · Census
80,406
Population
−2.0% in a year · Jul '25 · Census
+5,823
Net inbound search interest
Apr to Jun '26 · the wider Miami, FL area · 4,878 a year ago · Redfin home searches, not moves
Where it moved · 12 months
33036 · Islamorada · +3.0% · typical value $1244k
−6% or more−3 to −6%−1 to −3%within ±1%+1 to +3%+3 to +6%+6% or more
Blank areas: Zillow publishes no series for that ZIP. White with a grey outline: not enough history for this period.
Every ZIP in the metro
9 of 9 ZIPs · pick one for its detail · FHFA 5 yr is 2020 to 2025, published for 6 of them · Supply is months of supply from Redfin, readable for 7 of them
33036 · Islamorada · Monroe County
+1.3%
6-month change
ZIP 33036 · through Sep '26
+3.0%
12-month change
ZIP 33036 · through Sep '26
$1244k
Typical home value
ZIP 33036 · Sep '26
5 of 9
Rank in the metro, 12 months
1 is the strongest
Typical home value
This ZIP and the whole metro · 12 months · Zillow ZHVI, monthly
Sep '26$1244kZIP 33036$963kMetro
The long view
This ZIP · 2017 = 100 · yearly
2025194Zillow—FHFA
2020 to 2025: Zillow +71.7%, FHFA —. 2025 alone: Zillow −3.0%, FHFA —. FHFA’s ZIP index is yearly and experimental, so read it for the long run, not one year. Gaps are years FHFA did not publish.
What is happening in 33036
85 active listings on Oct 24, down 28% from a year ago. 33 sold in July to September, down 6% from a year earlier: 8.5 months of supply. Over the last 120 days 52 were listed and 45 went under contract.
30 days
Sep '26
60 days
Aug to Sep '26
90 days
Jul to Sep '26
120 days
Jun to Sep '26
Active listings at the start
99
102
103
107
Newly listed
9
20
41
52
Went under contract
11
19
35
45
Under contract ÷ active listings at the start
11%
19%
34%
42%
Same measure a year ago
8%
13%
23%
32%
85
Active listings
Oct 24 '26 · Zillow · 118 a year ago
33
Homes sold, Jul to Sep '26
Redfin · 35 a year ago
8.5 mo
Months of supply
Redfin · 10.3 a year ago
—
Days to pending
Zillow does not publish this ZIP
16%
Listings with a price cut
15% a year ago
53
Zillow market heat
Last 3 months, higher favours sellers · 50 a year ago
Zillow publishes under-contract counts by ZIP only by calendar month, so 30 days is Sep '26, and so on. Under contract is not sold: some contracts fall through, and they close weeks later. In this metro Zillow's under-contract counts came to 90% of Redfin's homes sold over the last 12 months.
Sold, last 3 months
Jul to Sep '26
3 months
Jul to Sep '25
a year earlier
Change
Homes sold
33
35
−5.7%
Pending sales
38
36
+5.6%
Newly listed
36
57
−36.8%
Active listings at the end
91
117
−22.2%
Months of supply
8.5
10.3
−1.8
Median days on market
157
132
+25
Redfin publishes ZIP figures as rolling 3-month totals, so its sold counts come in 3-month blocks rather than 30, 60, 90 and 120 days. Active listings here is Redfin's count at the end of the 3 months, so it differs from Zillow's weekly count above.
Listed against sold
ZIP 33036 · homes a month, averaged over 3 months · Redfin
Sep '2612Newly listed11Sold
Months of supply
This ZIP and the whole metro · Redfin, 3 months to each month · lower favours sellers
Sep '268.5ZIP 330367.4Metro
Gaps are months with fewer than 15 homes sold in 3 months, too few to read.
What usually comes next
Separate reads, side by side and never blended. They can disagree, and that is worth seeing. None of them is a promise.
+0.9%
Zillow forecast, next 12 months
Zillow's own figure for this ZIP. Zillow publishes only the current one, so we cannot test its record.
+1.5%
Trend carried forward, next 6 months
A projection, not a forecast or a buy signal: half the 12-month change, carried forward. Tested: only slightly better than assuming no change.
35% fell
Prices rising and 4 or more months of supply
Share that fell over the next 12 months. Typical result +1.3%.
Loosest third
Supply against this metro
6th tightest of 7 readable ZIPs here. In every period tested, the tightest third of a metro beat the loosest third 59% to 71% of the time, by a typical 0.4 to 0.7 points a year.
Months of supply
Readings
Typical next 12 months
Share that fell
Under 2 months
21,651
+3.5%
10%
2 to 3 months
24,706
+2.6%
20%
3 to 4 months
19,138
+1.4%
33%
4 to 6 months
19,854
+0.4%
46%
6 months or more · this ZIP
10,276
−1.0%
60%
Measured on 95,625 readings from ZIPs across the country with at least 15 homes sold in 3 months, taken Dec '23 to Sep '25 and checked against Zillow's value 12 months later. Readings from 2019 and 2020 rose in every band, from +13.6% down to +6.5%, so this ranks ZIPs. It doesn't call the market.
Buyers, sellers, moves and search interest · Key West, FL
Redfin publishes buyers and sellers for 50 large metros, and Key West, FL is not one of them. Over Jul '24 to Jul '25, Census estimates 1,931 more people moved out to elsewhere in the US than moved in, and +359 net from abroad. The population is 80,406, −2.0% on a year earlier. Over Apr to Jun '26, Redfin counts 15,980 of its users in other metros searching for homes in the wider Miami, FL area and 10,157 here searching in other metros: net inbound search interest of +5,823 (4,878 a year earlier). These are home searches, not completed moves.
Where movers come from and go to
Net people moving between Key West, FL and each other metro · IRS tax returns, 2022 to 2023
Most net movers from
Miami, FL+164
Chicago, IL+40
Baltimore, MD+38
San Diego, CA+14
Most net movers to
Orlando, FL−152
Tampa, FL−126
North Port, FL−112
IRS counts the people on tax returns whose county changed from one year's return to the next, so people who don't file are missed. Moves within the metro are left out, and so are flows too small for IRS to publish (under 20 returns between two counties).
Where the search interest comes from and goes to
Net search interest, Apr to Jun '26, between the wider Miami, FL area and each other metro
Most net interest from
New York, NY+3,577
Washington, DC+1,077
Boston, MA+911
Chicago, IL+807
Los Angeles, CA+630
Most net interest to
Orlando, FL−902
Cape Coral, FL−756
North Port, FL−300
Search interest is Redfin's count of its users searching for homes in another metro. It is not a count of completed moves. It covers the wider combined area around the metro, runs a quarter behind the sales figures, and leaves out searches within the area.
Neighborhood classes · Key West, FL
Each census tract's FFIEC income class. Pick a ZIP above to see the tracts inside it.